Andaluria: Blood & Desire · Monster, Myth & Humanity · October · Week 2 — The Things That Live Beside Us
Explore the Andaluria campaign →
STACY:
“I believed the grandmother.”
CAELWYN:
“So did I.”
STACY:
“She described a creature that could imitate kindness, recognise suffering, and hurt someone without any reason she could understand.”
CAELWYN:
“And you imagined a monster.”
STACY:
“Of course.”
CAELWYN:
“Until you discovered she was describing a human.”
Stacy closes the book.
“That’s what troubles me. Nothing she said became less frightening. Only the creature’s identity changed.”
CAELWYN:
“Tell me, Stacy. What makes a monster?”
STACY:
“Danger, perhaps.”
CAELWYN:
“A wolf is dangerous.”
“So is a bear.”
“And neither is necessarily monstrous.”
“Then appearance?”
“A dragon may have scales and claws. An elephant has enormous tusks. Neither tells us whether the creature is cruel.”
Stacy considers this.
“What about intelligence?”
“Does being intelligent make someone monstrous?”
“No. But it changes what we expect of them.”
“How?”
“If a creature understands that another being is suffering and deliberately continues to hurt it, we judge that differently from an animal hunting for food.”
Caelwyn nods.
“Yet understanding suffering doesn’t always produce compassion.”
“No. Sometimes people hurt others because they believe those others deserve punishment.”
“Then a monster might be someone who believes they’re doing the right thing.”
“Sometimes.”
“And someone who looks frightening might be entirely innocent.”
“Also possible.”
Caelwyn smiles faintly.
“We’re not making this definition any easier.”
“We shouldn’t. The consequences of getting it wrong can be terrible.”
CAELWYN:
“Consider a village in Andaluria. Children have vanished near an abandoned tower. A strange creature lives beneath it.”
STACY:
“And the villagers believe it took them.”
“They find the creature carrying a child’s cloak.”
“Did it abduct the child?”
“We don’t know.”
“Can it explain?”
“It tries. Nobody agrees about what it means.”
“And now the villagers must decide whether to kill it.”
“Before another child disappears.”
Stacy falls silent.
CAELWYN:
“If they wait, someone else may be harmed.”
STACY:
“If they act without evidence, they may murder an innocent being.”
“And if they call it a monster?”
“That word may make the decision easier. It doesn’t make the decision right.”
CAELWYN:
“Old traditions understood parts of this problem.”
STACY:
“Augustine considered whether extraordinary bodily forms necessarily placed a being outside humanity.”
“And Islamic traditions recognise moral differences among jinn, rather than treating every nonhuman being as identical.”
“Different traditions, different questions. But both remind us that appearance and origin do not automatically settle moral responsibility.”
Caelwyn looks towards the window.
“Then perhaps the real question is who gets to name the monster.”
“And who must live with the consequences.”
CAELWYN:
“Was the grandmother wrong to warn her grandson about humans?”
STACY:
“No. She knew what some humans could do.”
“But she also admitted that not all were dangerous.”
“And that she couldn’t reliably tell which ones were.”
“So what should the child believe?”
“That danger can be real without making every member of a people guilty.”
Caelwyn considers her answer.
“And what should a human do when someone fears them?”
Stacy closes the book.
“Don’t demand trust. Give them a reason to trust you.”
“How?”
“Keep your promises. Take responsibility for harm. Respect boundaries. Protect people when you have the power to hurt them.”
“And if they remain afraid?”
“Understand why.”
The fire crackles.
CAELWYN:
“Then what makes a monster?”
STACY:
“Perhaps we should begin by asking what it does.”
“And what it is?”
“That matters too. But we should be very careful about confusing the two.”
WORLDS THAT REMEMBER — CTA
In Mythveil Chronicles, a monster is never just a collection of statistics waiting to be defeated.
In Andaluria: Blood & Desire, your decisions shape how people and supernatural beings remember one another. An act of mercy may open a door. A broken promise may close it for generations.
A living world that moves on — with or without you.
Discover our campaigns and join the story:
https://mythveilchronicles.com/weekly-schedule/
Play Daggerheart: Andaluria — Blood & Desire on StartPlaying →